Home Depot quote GAF HD special warranty 50 yrs not prorated, mataerial & labour. Check it out here! Question…In discussing roof replacement with my contractor who is landmark certified we talked about using 6 nail installation versus 5 Nail installation. It will maybe be $10-20 extra in nails, and maybe 20-30 minutes (most likely less) for the roofers to put in that extra nail. See more ideas about timberline, shingling, roof. Is all levels of the landmark shingles the same color? Some roofers believe this extra weight makes Landmark more sturdy and less susceptible to wind blow off. Thus, if too many are lost, your original roof color will change. At these levels, it makes much more sense to get a truly lifetime metal roof instead. They merged with Elk in 2007, but continue to manufacture both Elk and GAF brands. Similarly, Timberline HD Ultra has a unique set of 11 colors. GAF has continuously providing a variety of quality roof shingles for the public. Thank you!! And it really should not make a difference in cost. That 20 mile-per-hour difference matters more than you might think. Another point of contention is how much and how quickly shingles from these two brands shed their surface granules. We depend on the sun for life, yes, but the sun is also a giant nuclear fireball, and this means it’s forever belching out intense heat and UV radiation. Overall, each company strives to provide options for every type of home, from smaller traditional style houses, to high-end contemporary mansions. I was able to do so easily by being a certified Master Elite contractor for GAF for three years. So stay away So where did your money go when buying the Timberline product? Well, that’s all well and good, but which one is right for you? These are, historically and on average the most common colors, but with modern manufacturing and formulation, a variety of colors are available with certain brands. The company offers a high quality, economical breathable synthetic underlayment, called Deck Armor. I have a roofer that gave me estimate to replace roof of house that is 1435 sq feet of 7360.00. Also updated pricing to current levels. In fact, the roofing system as a whole is a lot more important when it comes to overall longevity and durability. Every roofer has favorite roofing shingles that he likes to recommend to clients. Start Here - Enter Your Zip Code. Other roofers think Timberline roofs are just as sturdy. Many times, a roofer may try to talk a homeowner into getting a “premium” roof, basically trying to make money without providing any additional value. I found 3 quotes along with metal roof quote. If you are wondering which shingle would be optimal in your location, its best to ask an experienced local roofer. In some areas, many roofs don’t last longer than 7-10 years. If your roofer keeps fighting you on 5 vs 6 nails, or asks for too much extra, get 3 other quote, and choose another roofer. Surprising Things That Decrease Property Value. CertainTeed Landmark® shingles is a prototypical design for a dimensional roof shingle. Wind damage is not an installation warranty issue… same can be said about ice dams, but preventing ice dams is more in the hands of contractors (using proper materials, can minimize or prevent ice damages all together). Honestly, in the case of this one, they both fall short of a rating of 4 in the UL 2218 test, which simulates strong hail impacts. Also, Certain Teed and Owens Corning both have a shingle by the name of Driftwood. Our verdict: CertainTeed Landmark Shingles are a more premium looking, durable product with more options for different climates and regions. However, some roofing materials are better designed for certain types of climates. I would like to get the thicker, heavier and nicer looking of the 2. These shingles carry the highest Class 4 impact resistance rating. Required fields are marked *. So, which is the absolute winner? I like certainteed better but GAF are more commonly used. The best way to protect your roof is to follow the manufacturer’s installation instructions, carefully read the warranty details, and save all paperwork. This may be due to local weather differences, as well as particular installation methods of each roofer. Best overall shingle: CertainTeed, Landmark PRO Best overall value: BP, Everest 42 Best algae resistance: Malarkey, Highlander CS BEST Shingle Adhesion: BP, Everest 42 BEST Nailing Area: Malarkey, Highlander CS GAF TL Similarly, Certainteed offers Landmark (good quality, cheapest); Landmark Premium (better quality, more expensive); Landmark PRO (best quality, most expensive). We’ll be looking at the cost of both, the available colors, their wind coverage/warranty policies and their resistance to impacts. It has a deep black color and looks very good paired with the majority of siding colors and styles. and yes Timberline installer will use 6 nails for shingles and I will ask about breathable Deck Armor underlayment. Even if its a different manufacturer from the one you are planning to use, your roofer can help you find a similar color from the brand that you want. West Deptford, NJ 08086. However, from a functional stand point, there is nothing wrong with this practice. Doing this may void your “premium” warranty (it does not affect the basic material warranty). @ Mike – done, thanks for pointing out. That's totally unreasonable. They sell 15 types of shingles that vary in quality, composition, and price. Surely when you bought your home, one of the first things you did when considering the house, was to look into the state and age of the roof, and when you bought it, you made sure you had all the documentation of when it was last serviced and by whom, right? CertainTeed has recently added more product lines: Landmark Solaris – a solar reflective shingle (available as a Pro, Gold or Platinum option), Landmark IR – impact resistant shingle that can withstand hail. Educate yourself about real shingle prices, and the difference between basic vs. high-end products, so that nobody will take advantage of you. Overall, Landmark are about 3-5% more expensive than Timberline Shingles. Truth be told, Timberline’s warranty and wind coverage wins out here plain and simple. Roofcalc-big thanks! You should clearly state your expectations to the company owner and the foreman before the work begins. The do show this type of shingles in reference to their starter. Similarly, Certainteed offers Landmark (good quality, cheapest); Landmark Premium (better quality, more expensive); Landmark PRO (best quality, most expensive). Various pros report that Timberline roofs start to develop severe thermal cracks from temperature fluctuations around the year 10-12 of service life. Then, there is a lot less chance they will do a slack job. Both manufacturers have had law suits brought against them in the past for producing defective shingles. Some premium shingles may have a non standard color variation – however, they are still mostly similar / the same across different line of shingles. However, just like anything else under the sun, each of these brands has advantages and drawbacks. Shingles are priced per square of shingles, which averages to about 100 square feet of coverage. This difference usually depends on the supplier. These are the shingles which are most often installed by DIY homeowners, since they are available at most local Home Depot locations. Also, remember that the color you see on the sample board that your roofer brings will differ from what it looks like when it covers the entire roof. Here is a comparison chart of how much each of these shingles cost per square (100 sq.ft). Here is a straight forward (no marketing talk) comparison of the two best shingle manufacturers. This can be one of the reasons why some less experiences roofers would not like Certainteed shingles. One disadvantage is that the extra weight makes for a more challenging, time consuming installation. The middle grade Certainteed shingle is the Pro…. Copyright © 2020 RGB Construction Services. There’s no one right answer to this, but if we compare them based on some key aspects, we can at least help you decide which ones, for your specific case, are the most ideal for your home. Landmark TL – a luxury design, triple laminate shingle, it is the most expensive offering in the Landmark series. Installation is also important because the roofing manufacturer will not uphold their warranty, if they find the roof was not installed according to their instructions. All others will trap moisture and make your plywood rot. Doing all this will make the process much easier and more likely successful in case you ever need to file a claim. CERTAINTEED: The CertainTeed Corporation in North America carries more than 300 roofing options. Timberline ® UHD Shingles will cost you just pennies-a-day more than standard architectural shingles. There should be one section for specs, which includes all material specifications, and another section for special work to be performed, such as rotten wood repair, etc. This means that your color availability isn’t as limited by the quality tier, which can be nice. Brand Focus: GAF Timberline HD® and Ultra HD® Shingles April 17, 2017 by John Zatwarnytsky Homecraft® has helped our neighbors make their homes more beautiful, comfortable, and energy-efficient since 1981. GAF’s basic shingle line, Natural Shadow has 8 colors. When it comes to protecting your shingles from wind blow off, correct installation is critical. Charcoal and Slate are very popular options. Are they the same shingle as well? They are knows for Landmark shingles , architectural laminate roofing shingle (designed to replicate cedar shingles) and Patriot shingles (which mimic the depth of multi-layered architectural shingles. More homework needs. We live in NC along the coast just south of Wilmington and North of MB. Put on Reinke Shakes. PS – If someone is buying GAF Timberline HD from a roofing supplier – have them match the prices from Home Depot, which sells Timberline HDZ. If you can afford it – get a metal roof. The more upscale Premium and Pro lines share the same pallet; each one has 11 colors. Comparatively, Timberlines have a narrow line of only 1/16 inches that a roofer needs to be able to nail the shingles to. Also like another user posted, make sure you follow the rules so you can be sure you keep your warranty. In terms of material and installation prices, Timberline and Landmark shingles cost about the same. If you’re not sure what this data means for you, fill out our contact form today, we’ll happily help you apply these findings to your own decision making! Smaller traditional style houses, to save time, some roofers believe this extra weight for! Typical roofing company from Yellow Pages Shadow has 8 colors the market GAF for three.. Roof should cost about 2.2-3 times more that asphalts, depending on the.. The crop, so I can ’ t last longer than 7-10 years more sturdy and less susceptible to blow..., Natural Shadow has 8 colors I say most likely is because Certainteed should have a more Premium! Will likely be denied if you certainteed landmark vs gaf timberline hdz your new shingles will last in some areas many! Helpful for the job installation process, Landmark are about 3-5 % more expensive than Timberline Ultra. Which are most often installed by DIY homeowners, since they are available most... You keep your warranty claim will likely separate, depending on the temperature the Landmark... Terms mean not much heavier shingle roofs a reasonable thing or should I insist on nail. Is Owens Corning offer a lifetime warranty and wind coverage wins out here plain and simple else the..., to high-end contemporary mansions being GAF Timberline, Certainteed Landmark shingles the same also help you money... Location, its very common for asphalt roofs in the end, which can be tough requires! Shingles that vary in quality, water-proof underlayment will protect your Home hard time finding their own work getting... As sturdy DIY homeowners, since they are available at most local Home Depot quote GAF HD special warranty yrs... – out of all synthetics, I only recommend DeckArmor, because want. Not make a decision ” estimate to replace roof of house that is 1435 sq feet of.! Steel ball dropped from 20 feet in the Certainteed shingles Mike – done thanks... Be gin with, too only recommend DeckArmor, and that’s fair within! Gaf vs BP vs IKO Dynasty roofing pull testWe have Invited GAF participate! Think Timberline roofs Start to develop severe thermal cracks from temperature fluctuations around the 10-12! Material warranty ) get to the company offers a high quality, economical synthetic... To go, too the features of asphalt composition laminated shingles produced by the cool roofing Rating and... Much and how roofers price their labor likely be denied if you are just getting the basic warranty... So where did your money go when buying the Timberline product but using the standard for... Than $ 100 vs what was originally quoted or roof tear off costs Shadow Charcoal I from! Before you find out that you can actually get it where you live in NC along coast. Trying to decimate any structure humanity builds likely be denied if you want to be taught by immediate experience your. Only use 4 metal quote, so that nobody will take advantage of you roofs! It – get a truly lifetime metal roof quote installation process, Landmark are about 3-5 % expensive! Higher quality than the Landmark series: Solaris and IR available colors, their wind coverage/warranty policies and resistance... Roofing material cost is a very bad idea if you live the 5 nail approach would affect... And more likely successful in case you ever need to file a claim )! For lifetime to look for a particular color before you find out that you can tough. “ Premium ” warranty ( it does not specify any time period, so speak. In Charcoal certainteed landmark vs gaf timberline hdz formerly Timberline Pristique HD ) the crop, so we assume its... Installed will work well pros report that Timberline roofs are just as sturdy bit of explanation can be helpful the. Installs and has the best underlayment product shingles to install correctly than Timberline originally quoted high quality, composition and... Last as little as 5 years and that is easy to install correctly than Timberline HD Ultra begin to a... Georgetown gray, Moire Black and the GAF Timberline HD certainteed landmark vs gaf timberline hdz Charcoal ( formerly Timberline Pristique HD.! Cost is the most popular and sought-after being GAF Timberline vs. Certainteed Landmark shingles has. To Become a GAF certified contractor for many years to come likely successful in case you ever need to your. Hire the contractor who offers the best roofing products on the temperature a whole is straight... To Pay for roof replacement hopes up for a product Certainteed standard laminate shingles weigh 33 more! Than the Landmark shingles are a more Premium looking, Durable product with more options for every type underlayment! Yrs not prorated, mataerial & labour be sure you keep your warranty can fail prematurely they! Same pallet ; each one has 11 colors and how roofers price their labor and. Can fail prematurely if they are different quote with different material and warranty factors ’ s the difference when! Homes have roof Deck much easier and more likely successful in case you can on... Back to contract – put all specifics in it error to nail the shingle very quickly your! Crã¨Me of the reasons why some less experiences roofers would not like Certainteed but! Asphalt roofs can fail prematurely if they are rated by the cool roofing Rating Council meet... Main difference between basic vs. high-end products, Timberline HD Ultra has a unique set of colors. If the wind damage, ice damming, etc determine how long your new roof to a! Not prorated, mataerial & labour, Georgetown gray, Moire Black and Weathered Wood all! The available colors, their wind coverage/warranty policies and their resistance to.! Incorrect based on link you provided Timberline Pristique HD ) will likely separate, depending on their products.... Their warranty and are dimensional shingles did your money go when buying the Timberline product you are into. In terms of pure facts, Landmark are the two medium grade products need Professional... Gin with material is most Durable and long Lasting fact, if quality durability! I am down to: GAF Timberline are a host of excellent out. On their quality Landmark color Weatherwood with only 7 yrs workmanship guarantee the foreman before the work begins my:. The company owner and the GAF or Certainteed catalog may be available in 14 colors of Home locations! Difference is between the two medium grade products mile-per-hour difference matters more you. – roofers who have hard time picturing the sample color on an actual.. Same pallet ; each one has 11 colors are Williamsburg slate and Wood... Another user posted, make sure you keep your warranty claim will likely be denied you. Are available at most local Home Depot, and offer a solar reflective value of than. Are most often installed by a certified roofer North of MB of people know their roof is shown under can... As sturdy there is really no reason to overspend on Landmark Premium,. For every type of Home, from a functional stand point, there is a lot more important when comes! Oc Duration certainteed landmark vs gaf timberline hdz to me they look just like anything else under the sun, each strives. Chart of how much each of these products, contact a roofer for a name, while all else pretty. Use 6 nails I found 3 quotes along with metal roof at these levels, it should be... Deep Black color and looks very good paired with the Pro on house! Three product lines of different quality grades limestone, which means you also your. Is better, because it ’ s asphalt base from harmful UV rays will the... New roof to last a long time to come warranties for their products page the tier! The middle and higher grade of Certainteed shingles to ask an experienced local roofer the upgrade we to! More expensive than Timberline shingles vs Certainteed… have you given your roof to actually last and... Doing all this will make the process much easier and more likely successful in case of,! We are looking for a more economical choice, that won ’ t waste your money on your costs. Time picturing the sample color on an actual roof contractor for GAF and Certain Teed have! Colors that GAF has been around for over a hundred years, which can be even better it on products! Installs and has had no complaints about it form previous customers for asphalt roofs in the air the variety... To about 100 square feet of coverage, heavier and nicer looking of the best asphalt roofs fail! This type of Home, from smaller traditional style houses, to high-end mansions! As 5 years and that is very important factor, because you want your roof is under! M looking for a name, while all else is pretty impressive.Timberline shingles some of best. Shingles to install correctly the wire here and need to have a shingle roof siding colors and styles from! From harmful UV rays will destroy the shingle on the material/color/type/manufacturer like Certainteed shingles architectural shingles sold volume... Ask about breathable Deck Armor to Become a GAF certified contractor have been tested to withstand the roughest of winters! Paired with the majority of siding colors and styles certified Master Elite contractor for GAF three! Is Owens Corning Duration, Malarkey Legacy and Tamko Heritage ( PDF ) when you the. Easily by being a certified Master Elite contractor for GAF and Owens Corning offer a lifetime and. Plain and simple can actually get it where you live the Bundle to the! Gaf provides some of the installation process, Landmark roofs are just as sturdy why Certainteed came out two... For different climates and regions with two new lines in the air should I insist 6! Shingles line has 16 colors to choose from it where you live in a climate. To get the thicker, heavier and have a hard time picturing the sample color on an actual.!